This was asked on Twitter.I thought about it for a while and I came up with
C - Cole Aldrich - Merits include helping KU win a FF including presence in the semi final vs UNC. Back to back years averaging a double double. 2nd team All American, NCAA Champion... Honorable mentions Jeff Withey, Jeff Graves, Joel Embiid, Markieff Morris
PF - Wayne Simien - Career average 15 PPG and 8 RPG in 4 years at KU (2 under self). 1st team All American, 4 years over 50% FG%... 20 and 11 his senior year... Honorable mentions Thomas Robinson, Darrell Arthur, Marcus Morris, Perry Ellis
SF - Brandon Rush 13.6 PPG, 5.5 RPG average 3 years at KU, 3 year starter, lottery pick. NCAA Champion... Honorable mentions Andrew Wiggins, JR Giddens, Travis Releford, Xavier Henry
SG - Tyshawn Taylor - 4 year starter at Kansas. 10 PPG 4 RPG average over 4 years. 1rst team all big 12. 3rd team all american. Went to 2 Elite Eights and a NC game. Honorable mentions Keith Langford, Mario Chalmers, Ben Mclemore, Elijah Johnson
PG - Sherron Collins 13 and 4 career average over 4 years at KU. 2nd team All American 09, 1rst team All American 10, National Champion.
Overall resumes I think this is the most deserving 5. Collins should get his jersey retired.
C - Cole Aldrich - Merits include helping KU win a FF including presence in the semi final vs UNC. Back to back years averaging a double double. 2nd team All American, NCAA Champion... Honorable mentions Jeff Withey, Jeff Graves, Joel Embiid, Markieff Morris
PF - Wayne Simien - Career average 15 PPG and 8 RPG in 4 years at KU (2 under self). 1st team All American, 4 years over 50% FG%... 20 and 11 his senior year... Honorable mentions Thomas Robinson, Darrell Arthur, Marcus Morris, Perry Ellis
SF - Brandon Rush 13.6 PPG, 5.5 RPG average 3 years at KU, 3 year starter, lottery pick. NCAA Champion... Honorable mentions Andrew Wiggins, JR Giddens, Travis Releford, Xavier Henry
SG - Tyshawn Taylor - 4 year starter at Kansas. 10 PPG 4 RPG average over 4 years. 1rst team all big 12. 3rd team all american. Went to 2 Elite Eights and a NC game. Honorable mentions Keith Langford, Mario Chalmers, Ben Mclemore, Elijah Johnson
PG - Sherron Collins 13 and 4 career average over 4 years at KU. 2nd team All American 09, 1rst team All American 10, National Champion.
Overall resumes I think this is the most deserving 5. Collins should get his jersey retired.